Try the real TradingView setup for 7 days — $6.00 See the structured chart-analysis workflow in action before you subscribe. Eligibility and activation terms apply. Start trial
Article

Risk-reward and win rate: why a 1:2 setup can still lose money

A “1:2 risk-reward” sounds safe. But whether a setup makes money depends on how often it wins. The break-even win rates, expectancy in plain words and how to find your own numbers.

Risk-reward and win rate: why a 1:2 setup can still lose money
In this article
  1. What is risk-reward?
  2. The win rate you need to break even
  3. Expectancy: what a trade earns on average
  4. Why a “good” 1:2 can still lose
  5. How to find your own numbers
  6. A simple checklist before every trade

Many traders are told: “Only take trades with at least 1:2 risk-reward.” It is good advice — but it is only half of the story. A setup makes money only when its risk-reward and its win rate work together.

What is risk-reward?

If you risk ₹10 per share (entry minus stop-loss) and your target is ₹20 away, the risk-reward is 1:2. You aim to earn twice what you risk.

The win rate you need to break even

Because a winner pays more than a loser costs, you do not have to win every time. The break-even win rate is:

Break-even win rate = 1 ÷ (1 + reward per unit of risk)

Risk-rewardWin rate needed just to break even
1 : 150%
1 : 1.540%
1 : 233.3%
1 : 325%

Below these win rates, the setup loses money — before costs.

Expectancy: what a trade earns on average

Expectancy, measured in “R” (one R = the amount you risk), tells you the average result per trade:

Expectancy = win rate × reward − (1 − win rate) × 1

Win rateRisk-rewardExpectancy per trade
30%1 : 2−0.10 R (loses)
40%1 : 2+0.20 R (earns)
50%1 : 10.00 R (break-even)
35%1 : 3+0.40 R (earns)

Take the second row. If you risk ₹1,000 per trade, +0.20 R means an average of ₹200 per trade over many trades — not on every trade.

Why a “good” 1:2 can still lose

  • Your real win rate is lower than you believe, because you remember winners more clearly.
  • You exit winners early and let losers run, so the actual reward is smaller than the planned one.
  • Costs and slippage eat into a small reward more than into a large one.
  • You change the plan mid-trade, so the result no longer belongs to the setup you tested.

How to find your own numbers

Do not use a win rate from a video or a friend. Use yours: from at least 30 to 50 trades of one setup, count the winners, and record the reward you actually got. A trading journal does this counting for you and shows the result per setup, so you can drop what does not work and keep what does.

A simple checklist before every trade

  1. What is my entry, stop-loss and target?
  2. What is the risk-reward — and is it what I planned?
  3. What is my real win rate for this setup, from my own records?
  4. Is the expectancy positive after costs?

More articles

26 September 20264 min read

SIP vs lumpsum: which one suits you?

A SIP invests a fixed amount every month; a lumpsum invests everything at once. What each means, an example with numbers, and how to choose without chasing the market.

Read article

Ready to start?

Start a 7-Day Practical Trial for Just ₹199

Try TradingView Setup and MT5 Risk Manager yourself — no pressure, no rush. A disciplined, honest option before you commit to anything bigger.

Start ₹199 Trial Talk to us first
Risk disclosure

Educational tools only. No investment advice. No guaranteed returns. Trading involves risk. Yashdhan is not acting as a SEBI-registered investment adviser unless its legal status is explicitly updated.